Arkham City Identity Theft Locations Complete Victim Location Guide

Investigating the Identity Theft side mission in Batman: Arkham City requires patience and a keen eye for detail as you track down a mysterious killer operating in the shadows. The serial murderer leaves a trail of victims with missing facial skin throughout the open world, sparking a compelling detective case for the Dark Knight. Understanding where each crime scene is located and how to trigger the next phase of the investigation ensures you can solve this chilling mystery efficiently.
Finding the First Victim in the Bowery
The investigation officially begins when players stumble across the first crime scene located in an alleyway in the Bowery region. This initial victim is found near the center of the district, situated just north of the subway entrance between surrounding buildings. Scanning the body using detective mode reveals critical clues, including bandage fibers and boot footprints that establish the perpetrator's pattern.
After completing the analysis of the first crime scene, Oracle notes the sinister nature of the killer's operations. The game requires players to progress through a portions of the main story before the second victim becomes accessible. Keeping an eye on the surrounding rooftop communications helps ensure you do not miss incoming radio reports regarding further incidents.
Locating the Second Victim Near Park Row
The second body appears in an alleyway within the Park Row area, situated just south of the Ace Chemicals building complex. Players often locate this scene by following distress calls or patrolling the streets after completing several main story objectives. Investigating the scene reveals additional biological evidence and another set of precise surgical marks left by the culprit.
Analyzing the blood spatter and chemical traces at this location allows Batman to construct a detailed profile of the suspect's surgical methods. The killer uses sophisticated medical tools, suggesting advanced training and a deliberate, methodical approach. Following the forensic trail helps narrow down the possible motives behind these grisly crimes.
Tracking the Third Victim Near the Industrial District
The final victim needed to locate the killer's hideout is found lying in an alley near the alleyway on the western edge of the Industrial District. This crime scene is situated close to the outer walls, where a witness actually observed the murder taking place. Speaking with the terrified bystander provides direct confirmation of the suspect's appearance, matching Bruce Wayne's likeness.
Scanning the evidence at this third location enables Batman to trace the origin of the chemical agents used to preserve the victims' tissue. The forensic data points directly toward a concealed hideout located within a nearby apartment complex. Reaching this milestone marks the transition from field investigation to the final confrontation.
Uncovering Hush's Secret Hideout
With all three crime scenes fully investigated, a waypoint appears marking the entrance to an unmarked apartment in the Bowery. Entering the hideout reveals a grim medical laboratory filled with surgical tools, bandages, and audio recordings explaining the killer's obsession. Listening to the voice logs confirms that Thomas Elliot, known as Hush, is the mastermind behind the scheme.
Interacting with the central workbench triggers a cinematic sequence where Hush reveals his completed disguise and escapes the facility. Although he manages to evade immediate capture, resolving this quest line fully documents his profile in the Batcomputer logs. Completing this side mission provides essential progress toward achieving total completion in Arkham City.